When is it OK to put ice in your wine?   4 comments


Ice in Sangria?  De Rigueur and the only time I will do it.

White Wine Spritzer?  Never OK for so many reasons.

Wine on the rocks?  Hell no!!

We have a friend, a certain Ms. L, who drinks primarily (OK exclusively) whites.  She insists on the ice thing.  Reason?  She likes the clinking in her glass.  Reminds her of a party, I guess. 

Recently, she joined us with some other friends for a visit to one of the cathedrals of Italian wine and food excellence, Eataly in NYC.  After ordering a nice bottle of white, she proceeds to dump several ice cubes into her glass.  One of my other friends, Mr. M (a native of Piemonte) was about to have a seizure upon witnessing this.  I quickly shot him a look and whispered, “I know; just look away.”  But Ms. L, it seems is not alone. 

Is this behavior limited to people who are not wine professionals/critics/lovers?  Apparently not.  During a trip to Sonoma a few days ago, I saw a Dry Creek Valley winemaker do the same thing!  His explanation?  Gives him an opportunity to drink more without getting hammered.  Here’s an idea: DRINK MORE WATER.  Personally, I like Ms. L’s explanation better.

So why should this bother me?  It doesn’t really affect my enjoyment of the wine I happen to be drinking.  Or does it?  How much of a snob am I?  (Note to reader: these are rhetorical questions that I do not expect any of you to answer.)

Speaking of snobbery, is this any different from pouring a lesser wine when the people drinking it are not truly appreciative of, or willing to make an effort to appreciate, what’s in the glass?  Do you pour Petrus for the masses?  Hell, bad example, I don’t pour Petrus for myself.  But you get the idea.  People will tell you that they are not wine drinkers, until they find out that you’re pouring from a special bottle.  Then it turns out the unruly hoard is lining up for their allocation… usually a nice tall glass of the stuff.  “Fill it to the brim please.”  They are so polite.  They are also the first to say the wine is too dry and that they wished it was, you know, sweeter.  Ugh! 

But I digress.

So how do we solve the ice problem with Ms. L?  Even though I don’t care for ice in the wine, Ms. L is a good time and sure to keep the party lively.  Surely, that’s worth putting up with an ice-cube or two?  I keep some low-cost yet quality white wines in the house.  This way when it’s “bombs away” into the wine glass, I don’t feel as bad.  And I can drink the same thing.  And when she says, this is so much better than Santa Margherita!  I can respond, “And at half the price!”  All of a sudden, that ice problem just melts away…

Like what you see?  Hit the Subscribe/Follow button and don’t miss another Sybarite Sauvage post.

Posted May 7, 2011 by Sybarite Sauvage in Food-Wine-Love, Wine Etiquette

4 responses to “When is it OK to put ice in your wine?

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. What the hell… no no no … ice in wine never …

  2. Did I mention that the winemaker who put ice in his wine is of ITALIAN descent. He must have learned this from his elders, who in turn must have learned it from their ancestors in the “Old Country”!

  3. Syb, The problem is not you, but rather Ms. L – she is hanging around with wine snobs. She sounds like a blast and is welcome anytime at one of my gatherings – with ice! Hell, I’ll even make her a spritzer and have one mself!

    This world needs more fruitcakes and less bakers!

    • You know, Jimmy, this reminds me of the most Interesting Man in the World commercial: If I said to you, “It’s not you, it’s me.” I would be lying.

      Don’t be a hater, Dude.

      But just to show you I have no hurt feelings, if you send me your contact info, I’ll forward it to Ms. L. You never know, you might get lucky! Just remember the bard’s words of wisdom (and here, I paraphrase):

      Some people claim that there’s a woman to blame, but you know, it’s your own damn fault.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: